Telling tales

Telling tales peaks between the ages of four and eight, when children take rules very seriously. Telling tales aims to get someone into trouble; telling aims to keep someone safe.

Adults acknowledge minor reports without acting on them and hand the problem back, while making sure a child always feels able to report harm, bullying or worrying secrets.

Telling tales, or reporting another child's misdeeds to an adult, is at its height between about four and eight. Children of that age are learning rules and take them very seriously, and they have not yet learned to judge which breaches matter. The adult's task is to discourage trivial reporting without teaching a child to stay silent about things that are serious.

Why children tell tales

  • A strong sense of rules: a rule has been broken, and someone in authority should know.
  • A wish for approval: reporting shows that the teller knows and keeps the rules.
  • Getting a sibling or classmate into trouble, as a move in a rivalry.
  • Not knowing how to solve the problem alone.
  • Seeking attention.
  • Real worry that someone will be hurt.

Telling tales and telling

Schools commonly teach the distinction in simple terms. Telling tales is trying to get someone into trouble. Telling is trying to get someone out of trouble, or to keep them safe. Questions that help a child decide are:

  • Is anyone hurt, or likely to be?
  • Is anyone being bullied, frightened or left out again and again?
  • Is something being damaged or stolen?
  • Is it something that cannot be sorted out without an adult?

If the answer to any is yes, an adult should be told. If the matter is small and nobody is harmed, the child can try to deal with it or let it go.

Responding to minor tales

  • Acknowledge without acting: "Thank you for telling me. That sounds annoying." The child has been heard, and the other child is not punished on a report.
  • Hand the problem back: "What could be said to him?" or "What could be done about it?"
  • Ask the purpose: "Is this to help her or to get her into trouble?"
  • Avoid rewarding it: rushing to punish the accused, or praising the teller for being good, guarantees more.
  • Avoid shaming: names such as "telltale" or "snitch" teach silence.

Teaching other ways

  • Words to use directly: "Please stop. That is my turn."
  • Walking away and finding someone else to play with.
  • Ignoring small annoyances.
  • The steps for settling a dispute; see hitting and aggression in young children.
  • Stories and role-play in which a character decides whether to tell.

Never discouraging serious telling

A child must always feel able to tell a trusted adult about being hurt, bullied, touched in a way that feels wrong, asked to keep a secret that causes worry, or shown or sent something upsetting online. People who harm children rely on silence, and often tell a child that speaking would be telling tales or would cause trouble. Children are taught:

  • that nobody should ask them to keep a secret from their parents that makes them uncomfortable;
  • that surprises, such as a birthday present, are different from secrets;
  • that they will be listened to and not blamed;
  • to keep telling until someone helps.

An adult who is told something serious stays calm, listens, thanks the child and acts. Related advice is given under stranger danger, and what replaced it.

Between siblings

Much tale-telling at home is part of sibling competition. Not asking who started it, declining to act as judge and giving attention at other times all reduce it; see sibling rivalry.

At school

Teachers face the same balance, and most classes have agreed rules about when to fetch an adult. A child who is reporting constantly may be anxious, struggling to make friends or being picked on, and a conversation with the teacher is worthwhile.

As children grow

From about eight or nine, loyalty to friends becomes stronger than loyalty to adult rules, and children report less, sometimes too little. The message changes accordingly: keeping quiet about a friend who is in danger, being harmed or harming others is not loyalty, and getting help is the act of a friend.

Changed