Three painkillers sold without prescription are used for headaches: paracetamol, ibuprofen and aspirin. All three work for tension-type headache and for many migraine attacks. They differ in who can safely take them, and all of them cause headaches if they are taken too often.
Paracetamol
Paracetamol is the gentlest on the stomach and suits most people, including those who cannot take anti-inflammatory medicines. The NHS describes it as usually the best painkiller in pregnancy.
- The usual adult dose is one or two 500 mg tablets, up to four times in 24 hours, with at least four hours between doses and no more than eight tablets in 24 hours.
- An overdose can cause serious liver damage, even when the person feels well at first. Anyone who has taken more than the stated dose needs medical advice at once.
- Many cold and flu remedies and combination painkillers also contain paracetamol, and the total must be counted.
- People with liver or kidney disease, or who drink heavily, are advised to check with a pharmacist or doctor first.
Ibuprofen
Ibuprofen is a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug, or NSAID.
- The usual adult dose of the tablets sold over the counter is one or two 200 mg tablets, up to three times a day, with at least four hours between doses and no more than six tablets in 24 hours. It is best taken with or after food.
- It can irritate the stomach lining and cause ulcers and bleeding, and it can affect the kidneys.
- The NHS advises checking with a pharmacist or doctor before taking it for anyone with asthma, a past or present stomach ulcer, heart, liver or kidney disease, a blood clotting problem or a previous stroke.
- It is avoided in pregnancy unless a doctor advises otherwise.
- It is not taken together with aspirin or another NSAID.
Aspirin
Aspirin is also an NSAID and shares the same cautions.
- It must not be given to children under sixteen, because of a rare but serious condition called Reye's syndrome.
- It is not recommended for pain relief in pregnancy or, usually, when breastfeeding.
- It may be unsuitable for people with asthma, a stomach ulcer, heart failure, liver or kidney disease or a clotting disorder.
- The dose is taken as directed on the pack.
The low-dose aspirin prescribed to prevent heart attacks and strokes is a different use and does not relieve pain.
Using them together
Adults can take paracetamol and ibuprofen at the same time if one alone is not enough, according to the NHS, which suggests trying each separately first. Soluble or dispersible forms are absorbed faster, which matters in migraine. Branded and unbranded versions of the same medicine contain the same active ingredient at the same dose.
Codeine and combination products
Low-dose codeine combined with paracetamol or ibuprofen is sold in pharmacies. Codeine is an opioid, can cause dependence, and is the painkiller most likely to lead to medication overuse headache. It is not recommended for headache or migraine. Some headache tablets add caffeine, which slightly increases the effect and can itself provoke headaches when used regularly.
Medication overuse headache
Taking painkillers for headaches on too many days makes headaches more frequent. NICE gives the thresholds as fifteen or more days a month for paracetamol, aspirin and NSAIDs, and ten or more days a month for triptans, opioids such as codeine, and combination painkillers, over three months or longer. The NHS advice for people with migraine is not to take painkillers on more than two days a week.
The treatment is to stop the medicine. Headaches usually get worse for a time before they improve, and a GP can support the withdrawal and advise on preventive treatment.
When painkillers are not the answer
- Headaches that need a painkiller on several days every week call for a GP appointment, not a stronger tablet.
- Ordinary painkillers do not work for cluster headaches.
- Migraine that does not respond is treated with triptans and other prescription medicines; see migraine.
- A sudden, severe headache, or one with the warning signs listed under types of headache, needs urgent medical attention.
A pharmacist can advise on which painkiller is suitable alongside other medicines and health conditions.