Cosmetics described as natural or organic are made wholly or largely from plant and mineral ingredients, with few or no synthetic ones. They form a large and growing part of the market. The words on the front of the pack, however, mean less than buyers suppose, and the useful information is on the back.
What the words mean
- Natural has no legal definition for cosmetics in the United Kingdom or the European Union. A product can be called natural while containing only a small proportion of plant ingredients.
- Organic refers to ingredients grown without synthetic pesticides and fertilisers. Unlike organic food, organic cosmetics are not defined in law, so that a product may use the word while containing very little organic material.
- Certified products carry the logo of an independent body, which sets minimum percentages of natural and organic ingredients, restricts synthetic ones and inspects the manufacturer. Certification is the only reliable guide to either claim.
- Vegan means free from animal ingredients such as beeswax, lanolin, honey and carmine. Cruelty-free refers to animal testing, and is also best confirmed by an independent logo. The two are separate claims.
- Hypoallergenic and dermatologically tested are not defined in law either.
Reading the label
Every cosmetic sold in the United Kingdom must list its ingredients, in descending order of quantity, under their standard international names. Plant ingredients appear under their Latin botanical names, and water as aqua. Ingredients near the top of the list make up most of the product; those after the preservative are present in very small amounts. Fragrance allergens above a set level are named individually. A symbol of an open jar with a number shows for how many months the product keeps once opened.
Common natural ingredients
- Plant oils and butters: almond, jojoba, olive, coconut, argan and sunflower oils, and shea and cocoa butter, soften and protect the skin.
- Waxes: beeswax and plant waxes give body to balms.
- Humectants: glycerine, honey and aloe vera draw water into the skin.
- Clays absorb oil in masks.
- Essential oils and plant extracts give scent; see using essential oils safely.
- Mineral pigments colour make-up, and zinc oxide and titanium dioxide are mineral sunscreens.
Natural is not the same as safe
- All cosmetics on sale, natural or not, must pass a safety assessment before they are marketed.
- Plant ingredients are among the commonest causes of skin allergy. Essential oils, fragrance, lanolin and some plant extracts cause reactions in sensitive people, and citrus oils can make skin react to sunlight.
- Any product containing water needs a preservative. Without one, bacteria and moulds grow within days. Products labelled preservative-free are either free of water or rely on ingredients that do the same job under another name.
- Synthetic ingredients are not harmful merely because they are synthetic; many are milder and better studied than their natural counterparts.
- People with eczema or very sensitive skin generally do best with plain, fragrance-free products, whatever their origin; see eczema.
A patch test
A new product is tried on a small area of the inner forearm or behind the ear and left for 24 to 48 hours before it is used on the face. Redness, itching or swelling means that it is not used.
Reasons for choosing natural products
- Preference for plant-based and renewable ingredients.
- Concern for farming methods, wildlife and water.
- Avoidance of animal ingredients or animal testing.
- Liking for the scent and feel.
The claim that natural products are better for the skin is not supported by evidence one way or the other; what suits an individual skin is found by trial.
Packaging and waste
Solid bars of soap, shampoo and conditioner, refill schemes, glass and aluminium containers and concentrated products reduce packaging. A product with a short ingredients list and little packaging may do more for the environment than a certified one in an elaborate box.
Storing natural products
- Kept cool, dry and out of sunlight, with lids closed.
- Used within the period shown by the open-jar symbol; natural products often have shorter lives.
- Scooped with a clean spatula or dry fingers.
- Thrown away if the smell, colour or texture changes.
Products made at home are discussed under home-made skin care.