Discipline means teaching, not punishing. Between the ages of about five and twelve, children are able to understand rules, to foresee the results of their actions and to take a share in deciding both. Methods that work with toddlers, such as distraction and removal, give way to explanation, agreement and consequences.
What school-age children need
- A few clear rules, stated positively and explained: what is expected, and why.
- Consistency: the same response from one day to the next, and from both parents.
- Attention for good behaviour: children repeat what gets noticed. Specific praise, such as thanks for laying the table without being asked, does more than general approval.
- A say: rules that children have helped to make are better kept.
- Routines for mornings, homework, screens and bedtime, which remove many daily arguments.
Choices
Offering a limited choice gives a child some control without giving up the adult's decision: homework before tea or straight after, the blue jumper or the red. A choice is offered only where either answer is acceptable, and the child's decision is then respected. As children grow, the range of decisions left to them widens, and with it their responsibility for the results.
Consequences
- Natural consequences follow without adult action: a forgotten coat means a cold walk home.
- Logical consequences are arranged by the adult and connected to the behaviour: a ball kicked in the house is put away until the next day.
- A consequence is stated in advance, calmly, and carried out without further argument.
- It is proportionate and short. A week without screens teaches less than an evening, since the child stops connecting it with the cause.
- It is not used where safety is at stake.
The method is described in detail under natural and logical consequences.
Punishment and its limits
Punishment that is unconnected with the behaviour, harsh or delivered in anger teaches a child to avoid being caught and to resent the adult, more than to behave differently. Shouting, sarcasm, shaming in front of others and long lectures have the same effect.
Research consistently links physical punishment with more aggression and worse behaviour over time, not less. All physical punishment of children is against the law in Scotland and in Wales. In England and Northern Ireland the law has allowed a defence of "reasonable punishment" for a smack that leaves no mark, and its removal has been repeatedly debated in Parliament.
Staying fair
- The facts first: the child's account is heard before a decision is made.
- The behaviour, not the child: "that was unkind" in place of "you are unkind".
- Calm: a decision made in anger is usually too severe. Saying that the matter will be discussed in ten minutes is itself good discipline.
- The same standard for each child, allowing for age.
- A clean slate: once dealt with, the matter is not raised again.
- Apology: adults who admit to having been unfair teach children to do the same.
Solving problems together
For repeated difficulties, such as mornings, homework or fights between siblings, a conversation at a calm moment works better than a response in the heat of it. The adult describes the problem without blame, asks for the child's view, and the two agree on a plan and a time to review it. Listening is described under active listening.
Common situations
- Lying: usually to avoid trouble. Making the truth safe to tell, by responding more mildly to an admission, reduces it.
- Answering back: the adult states calmly how the child may disagree, and does not continue the conversation until the tone changes.
- Refusal: the request is repeated once, with the consequence, and the adult follows through.
- Behaviour in public: expectations are agreed before leaving home.
When to seek help
A GP, the school or a health visitor can advise where behaviour is persistently aggressive or defiant, is very different at home and at school, changes suddenly, or leaves the parents at a loss. Free parenting courses are offered by many councils and family hubs. Younger children are covered under disciplining toddlers.