Choosing a sleeping bag

Sleeping bags are tested to an international standard, and the comfort rating is the figure to compare with the expected night temperature. Down is warmest for its weight; synthetic fillings cope better with damp.

An insulating mat matters as much as the bag, because the ground draws heat from the body.

A cold night is the commonest reason for a bad camping trip. Warmth depends on two things together: a sleeping bag rated for the lowest temperature expected, and a mat that insulates the sleeper from the ground.

Temperature ratings

Sleeping bags sold in Europe are tested to an international standard, ISO 23537, which replaced the earlier European standard EN 13537. The label gives three figures:

  • Comfort: the temperature at which a typical woman sleeps comfortably in a relaxed position.
  • Limit: the temperature at which a typical man, curled up, is just warm enough.
  • Extreme: a survival figure, at which there is a risk of hypothermia. It is not a guide to use.

The comfort figure is the one to compare with the forecast night temperature, with a few degrees to spare for people who feel the cold. British retailers also use season ratings:

  • One season: warm summer nights.
  • Two season: late spring to early autumn.
  • Three season: spring to autumn, including nights near freezing.
  • Four season: winter, frost and snow.

Filling

  • Down, from ducks or geese, is the warmest filling for its weight and packs smallest. It loses its warmth when wet and takes a long time to dry, although water-resistant treatments help. Its quality is given as fill power, and certification schemes exist for humanely sourced down.
  • Synthetic fillings are heavier and bulkier for the same warmth, but keep insulating when damp, dry quickly and are easy to wash. They suit car camping, children and wet climates.

Shape and features

  • Mummy bags taper to the feet and have a hood. They are the warmest and lightest shape.
  • Rectangular bags give room to move, open out flat as a quilt, and can often be zipped together in pairs.
  • Length and width: a bag that is too large leaves cold air to be warmed; one that is too tight compresses the filling.
  • Details: a draught collar round the shoulders, a baffle behind the zip and a hood with a drawcord all prevent heat loss.
  • Liners of cotton, silk or fleece add a little warmth and keep the bag clean.

Mats

The filling under the body is squashed flat and insulates very little, so the mat does that job. Its insulation is given as an R-value, measured to a common standard since 2020: around 1 to 2 for summer, 2 to 4 for spring and autumn, and above 4 for winter.

  • Closed-cell foam mats are light, tough and cannot puncture.
  • Self-inflating mats combine foam and air, and are comfortable and warm.
  • Insulated air mats pack small and are the choice for backpacking.
  • Airbeds are comfortable but contain a large volume of uninsulated air and feel cold; a blanket or foam mat on top helps.
  • Camp beds lift the sleeper off the ground but still need a mat on top in cool weather.

Sleeping warm

  • Dry clothes, dry socks and a hat are put on for the night.
  • A hot drink or a meal before bed, and a hot water bottle, raise body heat.
  • Breathing inside the bag makes it damp and colder.

Care

A sleeping bag is aired after every trip and stored loose, in a large cotton sack or hung up, never squashed in its stuff sack. It is washed rarely, in a front-loading machine on a gentle cycle with a cleaner made for its filling, and dried thoroughly; down is tumble-dried on low heat with dryer balls to break up clumps. Other equipment is covered under camping for beginners and choosing a tent.

Changed